I thought leaving my daughter with her grandmother for one night would be harmless. But the moment she said, ‘Mommy, Grandma told me not to tell you…’ everything fell apart — and the police had to get involved….

---

I, Sarah, am at the most difficult crossroads of my life. My divorce from Mike has drained my energy and finances. And tonight, I have a crucial interview in Seattle – my only chance to win custody of my child. But the babysitter canceled at the last minute.

With no other options, I had to drive two hours to rural Eugene to seek help from the only person left: my mother, Eleanor.

We hadn’t spoken in five years. My mother was a harsh, eccentric, and reclusive woman. But I told myself: She’s still my mother. She wouldn’t harm her own grandchild.

The car screeched to a halt in front of the old oak house nestled in the pine forest. It was raining heavily. I quickly led my six-year-old daughter, Emily, up to the porch.

The door opened.

My mother stood there. She looked much older than I remembered. Her hair was a tangled mess of white, her woolen clothes were baggy, and she reeked of cigarette smoke – strange, since my mother hated it.

“Sarah?” Her voice was hoarse, like sandpaper scraping against sandpaper.

“Hello, Mother,” I stammered. “I’m sorry for being so abrupt. But I really need your help tonight. Just one night.”

Eleanor stared at Emily. Her eyes, usually a sharp, bright blue, were now dull and lifeless. She didn’t smile, she didn’t open her arms to hug her granddaughter.

“Come in,” she said curtly, stepping aside.

The house was dark and cluttered. Stacks of old newspapers piled high. The smell of dampness and… something sour, like spoiled milk, lingered in the air.

“What’s her name?” she asked, pointing at Emily.

I froze. “Mother… are you kidding? Emily. Her name is Emily.”

“Oh, yes. My memory is getting old,” she mumbled, turning and going into the kitchen. “Leave her here. Pick her up early tomorrow morning.”

I knelt down and hugged Emily. “Be a good girl. Grandma’s a little strange, but she loves you. I’ll be back tomorrow morning.”

Emily clung to my neck, whispering, “Grandma’s house smells awful, Mom.”

“I know. Just one night,” I kissed her forehead, my heart aching with guilt.

I hurried away, leaving my daughter behind the closed oak door. I didn’t know that it was the biggest mistake of my life.

The next morning, I returned to pick her up, feeling elated. The interview had been a resounding success.

Eleanor opened the door, still wearing the same clothes as yesterday. She looked agitated, her hands trembling as she handed Emily to me.

“She… she’s very good,” she said quickly, her eyes darting around the street. “Now go. I’m tired.”

“Thanks, Mom,” I offered her some money, but she slammed the door shut. The lock clicked immediately.

I helped Emily into the car. She was unusually quiet. Normally, Emily would chatter away, but today she just clutched her teddy bear, staring out the window.

“Emily, how was last night? What did Grandma give you to eat?” I asked, trying to break the silence as the car rolled onto the highway.

“Meatballs,” Emily replied softly.

“Meatballs?” I chuckled. “Probably just a sandwich. Did Grandma tell you a story?”

Emily shook her head. She turned to look at me. In the daylight, I saw a faint bruise on her wrist, like a fistprint.

My heart skipped a beat. “What happened to your hand?”

Emily pulled her hand back, hiding it in her coat. The little girl lowered her head, her voice trembling:

“Mom…”

“Yes, dear?”

“Grandma told me not to tell you…”

I pulled over immediately. The sudden braking sent both of us lurching forward. I turned and grabbed her shoulders.

“What did Grandma tell you not to say? Did she hit you?” I pressed, blood boiling.

Emily shook her head, tears streaming down her face.

“No. She said if I told her, the ‘boogeyman’ in the basement would come and take me.”

“Which bogeyman?”

“The man sleeping in the big refrigerator in the basement, Mom,” Emily sobbed. “Last night I was thirsty, so I went down to the kitchen. I saw Grandma open the basement door. She dragged a huge, smelly bag. Then she opened the horizontal refrigerator. I saw… I saw an arm sticking out. It had a snake tattoo on it.”

I was speechless.

The snake tattoo.

My father—who disappeared 10 years ago after leaving home—had a tattoo of a snake coiled around a dagger on his right arm. The police concluded he ran off with his mistress, but my mother never reported it or searched for him.

“Are you sure?” I asked, my voice trembling.

“Yes. She saw me. She ran up and covered my mouth. She said it was the bogeyman hibernating. She told me to keep it a secret, or the bogeyman would wake up and eat both of us.”

I looked toward the road leading back to the log cabin. A chilling horror ran down my spine.

My mother wasn’t living alone. Or rather, she was living with a dead body.

I didn’t go back home. I picked up my phone and called 911.

Thirty minutes later.

Two police cars and I stood in front of my mother’s house. I asked them to check my welfare based on Emily’s account.

“Mrs. Eleanor Vance! Police! Open the door!” The officer banged on the door.

There was no answer.

“We’ll break it down,” the officer nodded to his colleague.

Bang! The oak door burst open.

The police stormed in.

He went in, gun drawn. I ran after him, told to stay outside but I couldn’t.

The house was empty. Eleanor wasn’t in the living room.

“Check the basement!” I shouted. “The exit is in the kitchen!”

We rushed into the kitchen. The basement door was wide open. A pungent stench rose up, no longer the smell of spoiled milk, but the characteristic stench of death.

Under the flickering flashlight beam, I saw it.

A large industrial freezer sat in the middle of the damp basement. The lid was open.

But there was no man’s body inside.

It was empty. Only dried, black bloodstains and a few tattered pieces of clothing remained.

“She moved the body!” the officer exclaimed. “Seal off the area immediately! The suspect may not have gone far!”

Just then, a noise came from the dark corner of the basement. A figure lunged out, a gleaming cleaver in hand.

“Watch out!”

It was my mother. She rushed towards me, her eyes wide with rage, screaming meaningless sounds.

“Don’t even think about taking it! It’s mine!”

Bang!

The officer fired his Taser. My mother convulsed and collapsed to the floor. The knife flew away.

The police immediately subdued her. I stood frozen, watching the woman who had given birth to me being handcuffed, screaming like a wild animal.

But the real twist came when the police chief began a thorough search of the basement.

They found a hidden alcove behind a shelf of canned goods. Inside that alcove, they found… not one body.

But two.

And a pile of identification papers.

At Eugene Police Station, the inspector placed a file in front of me. His face was deathly pale, the expression of someone who had just seen hell.

“Ms. Sarah,” he said slowly. “The woman we just arrested… is not your mother, Eleanor Vance.”

I was stunned. “What did you say? She’s aged, but that’s clearly my mother’s face!”

“No,” the inspector shook his head. “The rapid fingerprint results are in. The woman’s name is Martha Higgins. A schizophrenic patient who escaped from Washington State Prison five years ago. She used to be a home care nurse.”

He flipped through the crime scene photos.

“We found two bodies in a wall cavity. One was male, long decomposed, with a snake tattoo – that’s your father, Frank Vance. He didn’t leave home 10 years ago. He was murdered and his body hidden at home.”

I covered my mouth, tears welling up.

“And the second body…” The inspector hesitated. “It’s an elderly woman. Quite well preserved in a freezer, probably recently moved out of the wall cavity to dispose of it. That’s Eleanor Vance—your biological mother.”

My world crumbled.

The truth was horrifyingly pieced together:

Five years ago, Martha Higgins—an escaped convalescent—had wandered into this area. She applied for a job as a maid for my mother, who lived alone after her husband “disappeared.”

Martha killed my mother.

But instead of fleeing, Martha realized my mother lived too isolated, her children never visiting. She—with a face strikingly similar to my mother’s and the skills of a psychopath—decided to become my mother.

She wore my mother’s clothes, dyed her hair gray, wore my mother’s glasses. She lived in that house, spending my mother’s pension.

And the secret about my father’s body? Perhaps my biological mother killed my father 10 years ago and hid the body. When Martha killed my mother, she found the body in the freezer. Instead of being scared, she considered it “insurance.” She kept the body, and later added my mother’s body to her collection.

Last night, Emily saw Martha open the freezer to check her “possessions.” She saw my father’s hand (the one with the snake tattoo).

Martha didn’t kill Emily last night because she was afraid the noise would attract the neighbors or that I would return unexpectedly. She intended to kill her this morning, but I arrived too early.

Emily’s words, “Grandma told me not to tell Mom…” weren’t the words of a grandmother. They were the threat of a demon disguised as a relative.

Chapter Conclusion

I picked Emily up from the counseling room. She was holding a cup of hot cocoa, her face calmer now.

“Mommy,” the little girl asked. “Has the fake Grandma been arrested?”

I hugged her tightly, tears soaking her shoulder.

“Yes, she’s been arrested, my love. The real Grandma… the real Grandma is in heaven. She protected you last night.”

I remembered Martha’s dull, vacant eyes when she opened the door for me. That coldness wasn’t the distance of a mother. It was the calculating look of a murderer trying to play the role of a human being.

If Emily hadn’t said that.

If I hadn’t believed her.

If I had left her there for another hour…

I shuddered, scooped Emily up, and walked out of the police station. Outside, the rain had stopped. The weak Oregon sunlight pierced through the gray clouds.

I had lost both my father and mother in the most cruel way. But I still had Emily. And I swear, I will never, ever let any door close between me and my daughter again.

The most horrifying secret is not

It lies in the basement. It lies right before our eyes, hidden behind the faces of the people we think we know best.