I CALLED A RANDOM NUMBER TO FAKE AN EMERGENCY — THE VOICE ON THE OTHER END KNEW WHY I LEFT TOWN IN 1998.

Part 1: The Coward’s Exit

The humidity in Oakhaven, Georgia, doesn’t just sit on you; it colonizes you. It had been twenty-five years since I breathed this thick, stagnant air, and within forty minutes of crossing the county line, I realized I’d made a catastrophic mistake.

I was standing in the foyer of my aunt’s Victorian home, surrounded by the smell of mothballs and overly sweet peach cobbler. The “Welcome Home, Elias” banner was drooping. My cousins, people I hadn’t spoken to since Bill Clinton was in office, were closing in with questions I wasn’t prepared to answer.

“So, Eli,” my cousin Marcus said, leaning against the doorframe with a predatory grin. “San Francisco, huh? You look… tired. Life out West not as golden as you hoped?”

I felt the familiar itch at the base of my skull. The Panic. It starts as a hum and ends as a scream. I needed out. Now.

I pulled my vibrating phone from my pocket. It wasn’t actually vibrating. I just needed the excuse. “Oh, damn. I’m so sorry, guys. I have to take this. It’s the firm.”

“On a Saturday?” Marcus sneered.

“High stakes,” I lied, already backing toward the porch. “Big merger. Give me five minutes.”

I stepped out into the heavy twilight. I didn’t have a call. I didn’t even have a firm—I’d been laid off three weeks ago. I just needed a prop. I opened my keypad and punched in ten random digits. I just wanted to stand there, phone to my ear, looking busy until I could find my car keys and vanish back into the interstate.

I hit dial.

Part 2: The Stranger

I expected a busy signal. Or perhaps a “The number you have reached is not in service” recording. Instead, it rang once. A sharp, digital chirp.

Then, silence.

I saw Marcus watching me through the screen door. I had to commit.

“Mom, I can’t talk—there’s been an accident,” I said, my voice pitched with fake urgency. I paced the length of the porch, looking at my watch. “Everything is a mess. I’ll have to call you back when I get to the hospital.”

I waited for the silence to continue so I could hang up.

“You always were a terrible liar, Elias,” a voice whispered.

The voice wasn’t my mother’s. It wasn’t a woman’s. It was a man, his tone dry and papery, like dead leaves skittering across a driveway. It was deep, calm, and terrifyingly intimate.

My heart didn’t just skip a beat; it hammered against my ribs. I froze. Marcus was still watching. I had to keep the phone to my ear.

“Who is this?” I hissed, turning my back to the house.

“You ran because of the fire,” the man said. The line crackled with a strange, rhythmic static—like someone breathing through a respirator. “Not the accident. You shouldn’t have come back to Oakhaven. The ash hasn’t even settled yet.”

Part 3: The Ghost of ’98

I felt a cold sweat break across my neck, despite the Georgia heat.

In 1998, Oakhaven suffered a tragedy. The Old Mill District had gone up in flames. Three people died. I left three days later with a duffel bag and a bruised eye, telling everyone I was headed for college early. I never looked back. I never spoke of the Mill. Nobody did. It was the town’s collective “hush.”

“I don’t know what you’re talking about,” I stammered. “I dialed a random number. This is a mistake.”

“706-555-0192,” the man read back. “That’s the number you dialed, isn’t it? My number. Do you believe in accidents, Elias? Because your father didn’t. Not even when he was holding the kerosene can.”

I nearly dropped the phone. My father had died in ’98. Heart attack, the papers said. Closed casket.

“My father is dead,” I whispered.

“Is he?” The man let out a low, wheezing chuckle. “Then who’s sitting in the silver sedan parked three houses down from where you’re standing right now? The one with the engine still running?”

I slowly turned my head. Three houses down, under the weeping willow that shaded the Miller’s driveway, sat a silver Buick. Its headlights were off, but I could see the faint vapor of exhaust curling from the tailpipe.

A silhouette sat in the driver’s seat. Perfectly still. Watching Aunt Sarah’s house.

Part 4: The Escalation

“What do you want?” I asked, my voice trembling.

“I want you to finish what you started,” the voice said. “The fire didn’t take everything it was supposed to. There’s a lockbox in the basement of the house you’re standing in. Behind the water heater. Loose brick.”

“I’m not doing anything for a voice on a phone.”

“Marcus is coming out to the porch, Eli,” the man said. “He’s got a knife in his back pocket. Not for the cobbler. He knows you’re not on a business call. He knows you’re talking to me.”

I spun around. Marcus was opening the screen door. He wasn’t smiling anymore. His hand was tucked firmly into his rear pocket, his knuckles white.

“Eli,” Marcus said, his voice flat. “Who are you talking to? You’ve been on that phone for five minutes and you haven’t said a word about a merger.”

The man on the phone whispered: “Run, Elias. Or stay and find out why the casket was closed.”

This second act ramps up the tension, transitioning from psychological unease to a high-stakes survival thriller. We shift the setting from the porch to the belly of the house, forced there by a combination of the stranger’s directions and Marcus’s mounting aggression.

---

Part 5: The Basement Trap

“Eli?” Marcus repeated, stepping onto the porch. The floorboards groaned. “You look like you’ve seen a ghost. Give me the phone.”

“It’s… it’s a bad connection,” I stammered, backing away.

“Give. Me. The. Phone.” Marcus wasn’t asking anymore. He took a step forward, and I saw the glint of steel in his pocket—not a kitchen knife, but a heavy-duty folding blade.

“Run into the house, Elias,” the voice on the phone commanded, cold and rhythmic. “The basement door is under the stairs. Lock it behind you. It’s the only way you survive the next sixty seconds.”

I didn’t think. I bolted.

I lunged past Marcus, catching him off guard. I heard him swear and the heavy thud of his boots as he turned to give chase. I slammed through the screen door, sprinted past my startled aunt in the kitchen—who dropped a tray of lemonade with a glass-shattering crash—and ripped open the narrow wooden door beneath the staircase.

I threw myself into the darkness, fumbled for the bolt, and slid it home just as Marcus’s shoulder slammed into the other side.

THUD.

“Open the door, Eli! Don’t be a fool! You don’t know what you’re doing!” Marcus screamed, his voice muffled but feral.

I stood there, panting in the dark, the smell of damp earth and rot filling my lungs. I realized I was still holding the phone to my ear.

“I’m in,” I whispered, my heart hammering against my teeth. “Now what? Who are you?”

“The light switch is to your left,” the voice said. “And stop asking who I am. Ask why your family kept the basement floor dirt instead of concrete when they renovated in ’99.”

Part 6: The Unburied Truth

I clicked the switch. A single, flickering bulb illuminated a cramped space filled with rusted garden tools, stacks of yellowing newspapers from the late nineties, and the water heater.

I moved toward the heater. My hands were shaking so violently I almost dropped the phone.

“Behind the heater,” I muttered, reciting the stranger’s instructions. “Loose brick.”

I knelt in the grime. The brick was there, marked with a faint, charred ‘X’ that looked like it had been branded into the clay decades ago. I pried it loose. Behind it sat a metal box, heavy and cold.

“Open it,” the voice whispered.

I flipped the latch. Inside wasn’t money or jewelry. It was a collection of Polaroid photos and a VHS tape labeled: JULY 14, 1998 – THE MILL.

I fanned through the photos. My breath hitched. They were pictures of the fire, but taken from the inside. High-angle shots of the flames licking the rafters of the Old Mill. And in the center of the frame, three figures stood in a circle, their faces obscured by shadows, holding hands as the world burned around them.

One of them was wearing a very distinct signet ring. A gold band with a cracked onyx stone.

The same ring I had seen on Marcus’s hand ten minutes ago.

“They weren’t victims of the fire, Elias,” the man on the phone said. “They were the architects. Your father wasn’t one of them. He was the one who tried to stop them. That’s why he had to ‘die’ of a heart attack.”

Part 7: The Silver Sedan

A loud crack echoed from above. Marcus was using something—a crowbar, maybe—to pry the basement door from its hinges.

“Why are you telling me this now?” I yelled into the phone. “If you know all this, call the police!”

“The police in Oakhaven are wearing the same rings, Elias. Look out the small coal window. Top of the wall.”

I stood on an old crate and peered out the tiny, street-level window. The silver sedan was no longer three houses down. It was parked directly at the curb. The driver’s door opened.

A man stepped out. He was tall, gaunt, wearing a suit that looked decades out of style. He looked up at the house, and the moonlight hit his face.

I fell off the crate.

The man was my father. Or a ghost that had aged twenty-five years in a grave.

“He’s coming for the box,” the voice said. “But he’s not the one you should be afraid of. Look at the photos again. Look at the fourth person. The one behind the camera.”

I scrambled for the Polaroids, my eyes blurring with tears. I found the one. It was a reflection in a window within the burning mill. The person holding the camera was a young man, barely twenty. He had a jagged scar running down his left cheek.

I reached up and touched the scar on my own face—the one I’d told everyone I got in a car accident the week I left town.

“You didn’t leave because you were scared, Elias,” the voice said, and for the first time, the tone shifted from cold to mocking. “You left because you were the only one who survived the backstab. You set the fire to kill them. But you missed Marcus. And you missed me.”

Part 8: The Twist in the Static

The basement door groaned, the wood splintering. Marcus’s face appeared through the gap, eyes wide and bloodshot.

“Give it here, Eli! We can still fix this! We can say you found it and were confused!”

I looked at the phone. “Who are you?” I screamed. “If you were in that fire, who are you?”

“I’m the one who stayed in the basement,” the voice said. “The one they buried under the dirt floor you’re standing on. Dialing this number didn’t reach a cell tower, Elias. Look at your screen.”

I pulled the phone away from my face.

The screen didn’t show a call in progress. It didn’t show a signal. The screen was black, dead, reflected only by the dim light of the basement bulb. Yet, the voice was still coming out of the speaker. Clear. Loud.

“I’ve been waiting twenty-five years for you to come home and dig me up,” the voice whispered.

The floor beneath my feet shifted. The dirt began to sink, as if something massive was breathing underneath the house.