The Girl Who Wasn’t on My List

I was the teacher assigned to supervise the girls’ dormitory that night.

It was past 10 p.m.
Lights out.
Silence.

As protocol required, I walked between the rows of bunk beds with a flashlight, counting softly under my breath.

“One… two… three…”

Everything felt normal.

“…thirty-eight… thirty-nine… forty.”

I stopped.

My hand tightened around the flashlight.

Forty students.

I frowned and counted again—slowly this time, carefully shining the light on each sleeping face.

Still forty.

But the dormitory registry clipboard tucked under my arm said something different.

39 female students.

No late arrivals.
No visitors.
No exceptions.

My pulse quickened.

I stood perfectly still, listening.

Breathing.
Soft snores.
The hum of the heater.

Then something happened that made my blood run cold.

---

THE UNTHINKABLE MOMENT

One of the girls—lying in the far corner bed—opened her eyes.

She was already staring straight at me.

Not confused.
Not sleepy.

Aware.

She slowly raised her finger to her lips.

“Shhh,” she whispered.
“You’re not supposed to notice.”

My flashlight slipped from my hand and clattered onto the floor.

Every other girl remained asleep.

Only her eyes followed me.

“Who… who are you?” I whispered.

She smiled faintly.

“I used to live here,” she said. “A long time ago.”

My legs felt weak.

“There was a fire,” she continued calmly. “They rebuilt the dorm. Changed the numbers. Forgot one name.”

I backed toward the exit.

My heart was pounding so loud I was sure she could hear it.

“You should check your old records,” she said softly. “The ones from before.”

The lights flickered.

When they steadied again—

Her bed was empty.

---

THE MORNING AFTER

I didn’t sleep.

At dawn, I went straight to the school archives.

Buried in a dusty file from twenty-two years ago, I found it.

A dormitory incident report.

Cause: electrical fire
Casualties: one student
Name: Emily Rowe
Age: 14

The number of students listed that year?

40.

I returned to the dorm that night.

The beds were full.

I counted again.

“One… two… three…”

“…thirty-eight… thirty-nine.”

No forty.

But as I turned off the lights, I heard a familiar whisper behind me.

“Thank you for remembering.”

The heater hummed.
The girls slept.

And for the first time since that night—

The numbers were finally right.