Twelve jurors and six alternates have been chosen for the Karmelo Anthony murder trial.
A pool that started with 589 prospective jurors was narrowed down after a day of vetting by prosecutors and defense attorneys, one controversial question that several prospective jurors refused to answer, and all qualified African American jurors being dismissed by the prosecution.
The prosecution argued that they thought that the circumstances surrounding the crime were “race-neutral” and should not require a diverse panel of jurors. Judge John Roach overruled the objection.
Karmelo Anthony appeared on a live camera feed sitting at a table with his attorneys, wearing a dark suit and tie, while his attorney, along with prosecutors, continued the work of finding a jury that would give him a fair trial.
Media coverage raises concerns about juror bias
When prosecutors asked prospective jurors if media coverage of the case had led them to form opinions, several admitted it had, with one replying, “I don’t know if it’s going to affect me, but I can’t tell you those thoughts are not inside my head.”
Another prospective juror who identified as an educator in the Frisco Independent School District, where both the defendant and victim attended separate high schools, said, “This is close enough to home that I’m not confident that I could be completely fair.”
Jurors questioned about defendant’s age, race and right to remain silent
Potential jurors were also asked if the age of the 19-year-old defendant, who was 17 when authorities say he fatally stabbed 17-year-old Austin Metcalf at a track meet, would influence their judgment, as well as his race.
One prospective juror whom prosecutors identified as African American said he would “…have a hard time putting a brother in jail.”
Anthony’s attorney plans to argue that the defendant stabbed Metcalf, who was unarmed, in self-defense after an altercation.
Prospective jurors were asked if they would hold it against Anthony if he didn’t testify.
One prospective juror admitted that it would, saying, “Silence is deafening; it matters. It’s difficult to ignore.”
Immigration question draws objections from prospective jurors
But Anthony’s attorney, Mike Howard, drew the ire of several prospective jurors when he asked them, “How do you feel about the country’s immigration policies?
A number of them refused to answer, saying it was irrelevant. Both the prosecution and the defense were allowed to dismiss 10 people.
The 12 jurors and six alternates were seated just after 5 p.m.
Opening statements will take place on Thursday morning.
News
THIS JUST HAPPENED: A quote from Carter is breaking millions of Yellowstone fans’ hearts more than the original series ending
For years, Yellowstone taught fans one brutal lesson: The DUTTONS would burn the world down before losing their land. And yet in the end… They lost it anyway. That’s the devastating emotional truth now haunting the entire Yellowstone universe after…
LANDMAN SEASON 3’S BIGGEST SECRET WON’T BE REVEALED ALL AT ONCE
The oil-rich empire of Landman is about to get even more combustible. Paramount+’s gritty Texas drama, starring Billy Bob Thornton as the no-nonsense crisis manager Tommy Norris, has already delivered back-to-back seasons of corporate intrigue, family betrayals, and explosive power struggles. But according to…
Just six months ago, my family was on the brink of collapse. And the one who brought my husband back from his delusion was none other than me
I STOLE MY HUSBAND BACK FROM HIS MISTRESS Just six months ago, my family was on the brink of collapse. And the one who brought my husband back from his delusion was none other than me. The day I discovered…
Part 2: They Laughed at My Thirty Acres of Stone Until the Valley Came Begging for Water
They Laughed at My Thirty Acres of Stone Until the Valley Came Begging for Water My name is Clara Whitaker, and for most of my life, I believed the worst thing a person could inherit was nothing. Then my grandfather…
Part 2: I Disappeared After Learning My Wife’s Baby Wasn’t Mine. She Found Me
I vanished the day I discovered my wife’s baby wasn’t mine. 5 years of peace in the Colorado Rockies until she found me. Not to apologize, to destroy me. She brought a lawyer, forged documents, and $175,000 in demands. But…
She Built a Hidden Shed Under Her Cabin — Then It Saved Her During a Snowstorm
She Built a Hidden Shed Under Her Cabin — Then It Saved Her During a SnowstormThe stranger pounding on Elizabeth Hayes’s door was going to freeze to death if she left him outside.Five minutes after she let him in, he…
End of content
No more pages to load